Showing posts with label חסידות. Show all posts
Showing posts with label חסידות. Show all posts

Sunday, February 16, 2020

דבר תורה לפרשת יתרו

זה דבר התורה שהעברתי אתמול בבית כנסת שירה חדשה בירושלים

היום קראנו בפרשת השבוע את המילים שבני ישראל שמעו ישיר מן הקב"ה:


אנכי ה' אלקיך אשר הוצאתיך מארץ מצרים מבית עבדים. לא יהיה לך אלהים אחרים על פני.

אז איך זה, שכמו שנקרא בעוד ארבעה שבועות, שרק ארבעים ימים אחרי, חלק משמעותי של בני ישראל עבדו את עגל הזהב?

התשובה שלי לשאלה הזאת מבוססת על הרקע שממנו יצאו בני ישראל מעבדות לחרות. בני ישראל גדלו כעבדים במצרים. למצרים היו הרבה אלים. אחד מהאלים האלו היה גם אל וגם בן אדם. אני מתכוון לפרעה, שהיה גם הגבוה ביותר מכל בני האדם וגם הנמוך ביותר בין כל האלים. ואז יום אחד חזר למצרים, לאחר היעדרות של כשישים שנה, בן אדם עברי בשם משה בן עמרם, שהציג את עצמו כעבדו של אל העברים, וששחרר את בני עמו מעבדותם לפרעה. זה לא פלא שהרבה מבני ישראל הסיקו שכמו שפרעה אמור להיות גם בן אדם וגם אל, ככה משה בו עמרם הוא באמת גם בן אדם וגם אל. וזה מה שקראנו בפרשת השבוע בשבוע שעבר:


ויראו העם את ה' ויאמינו בה' ובמשה עבדו.

כלומר, יש שני אלים. האל הראשי הוא הקב"ה, ומשה בן עמרם הוא סגנו. וכן, אחרי שסגנו של הקב"ה לא חזר מהר סיני אחרי ארבעים יום, בני ישראל בקשו מאהרן לעשות להם סגן תחליף למלא את מקומו של משה. וזה מה שנקרא בתורה בעוד ארבעה שבועות:


וירא העם כי בשש משה לרדת מן ההר, ויקהל העם על אהרן, ויאמרו אליו קום עשה לנו אלהים אשר ילכו לפנינו, כי זה משה האיש אשר העלנו מארץ מצרים לא ידענו מה היה לו.

ועכשיו לימינו.

בימי חז"ל, האלילים העיקרים היו כוכבים ומזלות. לכן, חז"ל קראו לפגנים "עובדי כוכבים ומזלות".

בימינו, האלילים הם בני אדם. דוגמאות ברורות מהמאה האחרונה כוללות היטלר בין הגרמנים, סטלין בין הרוסים, ומאו בין הסינים.

גם אצלנו היהודים יש בני אדם שהם אלילים. קוראים להם 'אדמו"רים'. החסיד הטיפוסי נותן לאדמו"ר שלו את הכבוד והיראה שראויים רק לאל, ולא לבן אדם. אני אקרא לכם קטע ממאמר שהופיע במקור ראשון לפני שלשה וחצי חודשים. הכתב מתאר ילד בן 12 מחסידי גור שבמקרה היה יחד עם הכתב, גם בן 12, בישיבת בין הזמנים של בית כנסת ליטאי.


כדרכם של ילדים נהנינו להקניט את החסיד הצעיר... ההקנטות על גור ומנהיגיה נתקלו בחומה בצורה של גאיות יחידה, אך כשהעזנו לנקוב בשמו המפורש של רבי יעקב אריה אלתר, האדמו"ר מגור, הוא היה רודף וחובט בנו, לא לפני שלחש בזעזוע 'ברוך שם כבוד מלכותו'.

לפני שאני ממשיך, אני חייב להבהיר שאינני מדבר על חסידות. אני מדבר דווקא על החסידים, שהפכו את האדמו"רים שלהם לאלילים. אני גם לא מאשים את האדמו"רים הראשונים, הבעל שם טוב, תלמידיו, ותלמידי תלמידיו. הם רצו להיות מדריכים רוחניים לפשוטי עם ישראל. אלא שפשוטי עם ישראל הפכו אותם ואת הבאים אחריהם לאלילים. ועלינו להכיר שזה כבר מאתיים שנה שהחסידים מקיימים רק תרי"ב מצוות. הם מקיימים את כל מצוות התורה חוץ מ-"לא יהיה לכם אלהים אחרים על פני".


Wednesday, January 1, 2020

King Arthur and the Lubavitcher Rebbe

Here is a transcription starting at about 1:23:45 of Exploring The Lord of The Rings Episode 68:

So I mean if you said of a human, like an old human hero who had died, you know, "where he dwells now nobody can say", you're just being evasive, right, probably unless it's King Arthur, but generally you're being evasive if you talk like that.
Or unless it's the Lubavitcher Rebbe.


Tuesday, March 5, 2019

Yaakov Yosef of Polonnoye - Postscript

The author of the Encyclopedia Judaica article is Moshe Halamish. I googled him to try to find on-line something else he has published, in order to gauge his attitude towards Hassidut. I found this article about Shneur Zalman of Liadi. I see no indication there that Prof. Halamish is hostile to Hassidut. So maybe his Encyclopedia Judaica article really is an accurate description of Yaakov Yosef's doctrine of the zaddik. That implies that Yaakov Yosef, and by implication also the Ba'al Shem Tov, thought that the cult of the zaddik is a good thing, or at least a necessary evil for confronting the crisis in 18th century Eastern European Judaism. I will be דן לכף זכות and posit that they didn't realize how easy it is for a charismatic psychopath like Eliezer Berland to pass himself off as a zaddik.

Monday, March 4, 2019

Yaakov Yosef of Polonnoye - Maybe a Smoking Knife?

Here is the last paragraph of the Encyclopedia Judaica article about Jacob Joseph Ben Zevi Hakohen Katz of Polonnoye:
The "man of matter" must also support the zaddik financially to enable him to fulfill his duty successfully and devote himself to God through Torah study and prayer. Jacob Joseph taught the importance of the communal Sabbath "third meal" for the hassidic congregation, saying that he who does not participate in it with his brethren "makes the Sabbath profane" (Toledot Ya'akov Yosef, beginning of the section on Noah). Jacob Joseph's hostility to the ordinary type of rabbi is expressed in his denunciation of them as "Jewish demons, the equivalent of the Satan and the evil inclination itself, the whole of their Torah studies being for their personal aggrandizement."
So here is a comparison of Yaakov Yosef's (alleged) doctrine with some checklist items, for telling whether a religious movement is a cult, from this Web page, "Checklist of Cult Characteristics", of cult recovery 101:

Checklist:
The group is focused on a living leader to whom members seem to display excessively zealous, unquestioning commitment.
zaddik:
The zaddik is likened to the head or eyes of the body, and the multitude to the feet. The congregation is thus conceived as a living organism, the zaddik being the life and soul of his generation.
 Checklist:
The group is preoccupied with making money.
zaddik:
 The "man of matter" must also support the zaddik financially to enable him to fulfill his duty successfully and devote himself to God through Torah study and prayer.
Checklist:
Questioning, doubt, and dissent are discouraged or even punished.
zaddik:
He is enjoined to believe in the zaddik with absolute faith, without any afterthoughts or doubts as to the zaddik's way of life, because all his actions are performed for the sake of Heaven.
Checklist:
The leadership dictates sometimes in great detail how members should think, act, and feel (for example: members must get permission from leaders to date, change jobs, get married; leaders may prescribe what types of clothes to wear, where to live, how to discipline children, and so forth).
zaddik:
None of the members can adhere truly to God, so long as only one, even if an ignoramus, is non conscious of his need to be uplifted through the head (the zaddik). Hence it is the duty of the zaddik to exeert his influence over him.
Checklist:
The group has a polarized us-versus-them mentality, which causes conflict with the wider society.
zaddik:
 Jacob Joseph's hostility to the ordinary type of rabbi is expressed in his denunciation of them as "Jewish demons, the equivalent of the Satan and the evil inclination itself, the whole of their Torah studies being for their personal aggrandizement."
Checklist:
The group’s leader is not accountable to any authorities (as are, for example, military commanders and ministers, priests, monks, and rabbis of mainstream denominations).
The group teaches or implies that its supposedly exalted ends justify means that members would have considered unethical before joining the group (for example: collecting money for bogus charities).
zaddik:
Moreover, for the sake of this unification with the multitude, and so as to be able to uplift it, the zaddik may sometimes have to descend from his own level and to sin for the good of his task.
Checklist:
The leadership induces guilt feelings in members in order to control them.
Members’ subservience to the group causes them to cut ties with family and friends, and to give up personal goals and activities that were of interest before joining the group.
Members are encouraged or required to live and/or socialize only with other group members.
zaddik:
 Jacob Joseph taught the importance of the communal Sabbath "third meal" for the hassidic congregation, saying that he who does not participate in it with his brethren "makes the Sabbath profane"
 Hassidut, as defined by Yaakov Yosef according to the Encyclopedia Judaica article, sure looks like a cult!, It quacks like a cult, it has webbed feet like a cult, and it lays eggs like a cult.

OTOH the Encyclopedia Judaica article is a (probably biased) tertiary source, which is why I was doing quick and dirty keyword searches in בן פורת יוסף and תולדות יעקב יוסף - בראשית שמות ויקרא: I want to know whether Yaakov Yosef really thought that way about the relationship between the zaddik and his followers.

The bibliography of the Encyclopedia Judaica article includes The zaddik: the doctrine of the zaddik according to the writings of Rabbi Yaakov Yosef of Polnoy, by Samuel H. Dresner. I perused that book at the Hebrew Union College library in Jerusalem. As I expected, it is a secondary source with lots of quotes from Yaakov Yosef's writings. Unlike the Encyclopedia Judaica article, that book is biased in favor of Hassidut. It presents the zaddik as the Baal Shem Tov's proposed solution to the problem of the sterility of Jewish religious life in 18th century Eastern Europe. The book describes the character and mission of the zaddik, including how the zaddik is supposed to relate to ordinary Jews (and BTW the "sins" that the zaddik commits in pursuit of his mission are limited to trivial matters like skipping Minha in order to help a fellow Jew), but says nothing about how ordinary Jews are supposed to relate to the zaddik, so it is not useful in determining whether the Encyclopedia Judaica's cult-like description of Hassidut as envisioned by Yaakov Yosef is accurate. I need to look at other sources in the bibliography.

Sunday, March 3, 2019

Yaakov Yosef of Polonnoye - No Smoking Gun

Yesterday I was at this sheur. The only חסידות that Menahem Lorberbaum spoke about was that of Yaakov Yosef of Polonoyye, one of the students of the Baal Shem Tov. When I got home I looked him (Yaakov Yosef, not Menahem) in Encyclopedia Judaica (first edition), where he is called "Jacob Joseph Ben Zevi Ha-Kohen Katz of Polonnoye".

Here is the next to last paragraph:
The same relationship within man also exists within society. There is the "multitude" and the "scholar". The man of merit and form is the zaddik, while the "multitude" is matter. The zaddik is likened to the head or the eyes of the body, and the multitude to the feet. The cngregation is thus conceived as a living organism, the zaddik being its life and soul in his generation/ This organismic premise precludes the concept that only a few are elect. It follows that the interrelationship in this corporate body causes any failure on the part of even the lowest member - whether in matter or in spirit - to be reflected far more damagingly in the state of "the head" - the zaddik. None of the members can adhere truly to God, so long as only one, even if an ignoramus, is not conscious of his need to be uplifted through the head (the zaddik). Hence it is the duty of the zaddik to exert his influence over him. Moreover, for the sake of this unification with the multitude, and so as to be able to uplift it, a zaddik may sometimes have to descend from his own level and to sin for the good of his task. This concept of the "descent of the zaddik" holds an important place in Jacob Joseph's teachings. The Jew of the multitude is incapable "of studying the Torah, and as this is through no neglect of his own, God will not punish him" if he adheres to the zaddik". He is enjoined to believe in the zaddik with absolute faith, without any afterthoughts or doubts as to the zaddik's way of life, because all of his actions are performed for the sake of Heaven.
That last sentence suggested to me that I might find in the writings of Yaakov Yosef a smoking gun to support my thesis that Hassidut is idolatrous, and more, that it was idolatrous from the very beginning. Some quick keyword searches in בן פורת יוסף and   תולדות יעקב יוסף - בראשית שמות ויקרא
came up dry. If I want to get serious about this I will have to look at the article's bibliography, but right now that paragraph looks like just ordinary egomaniacal moral corruption, not actual self-deification.