Showing posts with label קרבנות. Show all posts
Showing posts with label קרבנות. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 7, 2021

The Agenda of Shir HaShirim

 On the last day of Pesah (in Israel) this year we read Shir HaShirim.

It occurred to me that the opposition to sacrificial worship that I expressed in my posts of 16 April 2018 and 3 May 2018 may have an ancient antecedent. But I will get to that at the end. I will start with a more general interpretation of the agenda of the unknown author (not King Shlomo) of Shir HaShirim.

(There is lots of linguistic evidence that Shir HaShirim was written in Second Temple times. For what I add at the end of this post, it has to be early Second Temple times. But still Second Temple. So the author can't be King Shlomo.)

I accept that the author's agenda is a metaphorical presentation of the relationship of Israel and God.  I disagree with the standard presentation of that relationship. The author's intent is to reject institutional religion as the true way to relate to God, and to advocate personal relationships.

The structure of the book is a multi-speaker dialogue. The back story is that a girl in her early teens has been recruited to join a king's harem in Jerusalem. Unfortunately, she is already in love with a young shepherd.

The speakers are:

The girl

The shepherd (as imagined by the girl)

The girl's family (as imagined by the girl)

Other girls in Jerusalem

The king

Now I will divide the book by chapter and verse, according to who is speaking. I won't interpret any of the verses in detail, other than to note that Chapter 3 verses 9-11 are dripping with sarcasm.

Chapter 1 verse 1: the author

Chapter 1 verses 2-7: the girl

Chapter 1 verse 8: the other girls

Chapter 1 verses 9-11: the king

Chapter 1 verses 12-13: the girl

Chapter 1 verse 14: the shepherd

Chapter 1 verse 15 - Chapter 2 verse 1: the girl

Chapter 2 verse 2: the shepherd

Chapter 2 verses 3-13: the girl

Chapter 2 verse 14: the shepherd

Chapter 2 verse 15 - Chapter 3 verse 5: the girl

Chapter 3 verses 6-8: the king

Chapter 3 verses 9-11: the girl

Chapter 4 verse 1 - Chapter 5 verse 1: the king

Chapter 5 verses 2-8: the girl

Chapter 5 verse 9: the other girls

Chapter 5 verses 10-16: the girl

Chapter 6 verse 1: the other girls

Chapter 6 verses 2-3: the girl

Chapter 6 verses 4-10: the king

Chapter 6 verse 11-12 the girl

Chapter 7 verses 1-11 : the king (except that second half of verse 1 is spoken by the girl)

Chapter 7 verse 12 - Chapter 8 verse 4: the girl

Chapter 8 verse 5: the shepherd

Chapter 8 verses 6-7: the girl

Chapter 8 verses 8-9: the girl's family

Chapter 8 verses 10-12: the girl

Chapter 8 verse 13: the shepherd

Chapter 8 verse 14: the girl

I follow the standard interpretation of the metaphor, that the girl is Israel and that both the shepherd and the king are God, except that the girl loves only the shepherd and wishes she could escape the king and return to the shepherd. Institutionalized religiosity ("love" of the king) is bad. Personal religiosity (love of the shepherd) is good.

Now as to why this can be interpreted as objecting to rebuilding the Temple. The king is specifically Shlomo, who built the First Temple. "Love" of Shlomo represents centralized sacrificial worship. That is rejected in favor of unique personal relationships with God.

Of course, that is not the only possible interpretation. For example, the author may have been living in Bavel, and may have been rejecting the idea of returning from Bavel to Israel. The "love" of the king represents a collective relationship with God in an ethnically defined territory. The love of the shepherd represents individual relationships with God anywhere.

Sunday, April 15, 2018

All Jews are Mamzerim III

Another consequence of all Jews being statistically mamzerim is that, despite what The Temple Institute says, it is forbidden to renew sacrificial worship. If all Jews are statistically mamzerim, it follows that all male descendants of Aaron  are statistically halalim, and so are not kohanim. Sacrificial worship requires the participation of kohanim. For example, the sacrifice of an animal includes at least four steps: slaughtering the animal, collecting some of its blood, carrying the blood to the altar, and offering the blood on the altar. Only the first step may be performed by a non-kohen.

A halal (חלל) is the son of a kohen and a woman whom he is forbidden to marry. Those who want to renew sacrificial worship might argue that the son of a kohen who is "just" a halal (for example, a son of a kohen and a divorcee) may participate in sacrificial worship. As RaMBaM states (הלכות ביאת מקדש ו:י)
כהן שעבד ונבדק ונמצא חלל עבודתו כשירה לשעבר ואינו עובד להבא ואם עבד לא חילל שנאמר ברך י"י חילו ופועל ידיו תרצה אף חולין שבו תרצה
Chabad translation:
When a priest performed service and afterwards, his [genealogy] was checked and it was discovered that he was a challal, his previous service is acceptable, but he may not serve in the future. If, however, he does [continue] to serve, he does not desecrate the service. [This is derived from Deuteronomy 33:11]: "May God bless His legion and find acceptable the work of his hand." [implied is that] He will find acceptable even the desecrated among them.
But this is not the case for a halal who is also a mamzer. The Encyclopedia Talmudit article on halal says that there are differences of opinion among the Rishonim about whether sacrificial worship by a kohen mamzer is valid retroactively; but nobody maintains that a kohen mamzer is allowed to participate a priori in sacrificial worship. RaSHBA (reference 466 there) distinguishes between sons of women who are prohibited only to kohanim (פסולי כהונה), to whom Devarim 33:11 applies, and sons of women who are prohibited to Jews generally (פסולי קהל), to whom Devarim 33:11 does not apply.